Shopping & Dining
Shopping in Greencastle is a return to the days before the “big box” stores. Independently owned shops offer personal customer service and friendly atmosphere as you browse for the perfect item that meets your unique need.
Storefronts in the downtown area include clothing, shoes, antiques, country decor, and gifts, as well as personal services including a barbershop, tattoo studio, financial and legal services, physical therapy and insurance. Surrounding downtown you’ll find sign retailers, hardware, lumber and flooring resources, pharmacy and grocery stores.
Some of Greencastle’s unique shops include The Center of Balance on N. Jefferson St. which offers holistic wellness and artistic gifts. Chris Johnston’s wonderful store full of treasures at the shop and Lori Hess’ All Things Country, both on East Baltimore St., as well as The Dapper House Barbershop, a trendy, popular destination for men’s cuts & shaves. Just north on Allison St. is Alternative Choices, a virtual treasure trove of products to help keep you healthy and happy.
In addition to our downtown area, we have a number of other attractions and businesses that support our local community. Formerly located on E. Baltimore, The Jewelry Shop is now located at 11891 Molly Pitcher Highway and offers custom design and personalized service. As you drive north into Greencastle on Route 11, you will be met by a number of great retail shops, businesses and eateries including Antrim Way Honda–which is much more than a beautiful showroom of cars. They boast a wonderful cafe, a walking track, a putting green and a retail gift shop which are all open to the public. Across the street is the ever popular Mikie’s Ice Cream and Green Cow Gift Shop and the John Allison Public House.
Continue north on Route 11 and you will encounter Carl’s Drug Store, one of the oldest running pharmacies in the country! Sunnyway Diner and the newly renovated Sunnyway Foods are across the street and perfect for a bite to eat or to shop for dinner. Turn right at the light on Walter Avenue and visit Lumber Direct for your house ware and hardware needs. Just across the lot you’ll find the Farmer’s Union Co-op for your pet and farm supplies, as well as B&B Grooming.
Greencastle is home to a variety of restaurants from Mexican to Chinese cuisine, as well as American and Italian. We have a variety of venues to satisfy every appetite and every palette. Please patronize our members at the following delicious venues:
Sample traditional pub fare at the John Allison Public House at 155 South Antrim Way.
B Street 104 serves American fare, offers happy hour, and a variety of appetizers, sandwiches, and delicious dinners. The address is in the name! 104 E. Baltimore Street, one of Greencastle’s most historic buildings.
Home cooking deliciousness at Sunnyway Diner, 140 North Antrim Way will leave you satisfied and longing for mom’s cooking.
Tony’s Pizza at 42 South Antrim Way will make you think you’re in New York City.
Brother’s Pizza, at 50 Pine Drive, offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Mikie’s Ice Cream and Gift Shop is a great place to eat, lick and shop.
A local favorite with fresh energy, Lizzy’s Restaurant highlights the simplicity of ingredients and producing quality food made from scratch.
Antrim Way Honda isn’t just cars! Stop in at the Cafe for a unique experience.
Vinnie’s on 11 is a great place to dine in or out! With a great selection of traditional Italian or American cuisine, you can dine in, take out, or eat on on their patio adjacent to the restaurant.